Lyrics Part 1: I Need Sunshine

So Wolf Parade has two lead singers. One sounded like a smoke-addict fresh off a fight, and the other prat out his lyrics like David Bowie probably does before he has his morning coffee. If those adjective riddled descriptions didn't make clear enough, I haven't the faintest clue what they are saying most of the time. And yet I am very moved by the intonation of their voices, the grimace of their face, and roar that comes from the mic.
For years I have clung to the view that melody is infinitely more important to a song than lyrics. Though I do admit a wonderful little couplet will help shape the meaning of a song, great lyrics sung without regard to musical accompaniment are worthless. I made out about three words the entire Wolf Parade concert, "I NEED SUNSHINE", which were sung during my favorite song of theirs. The name of that song? I don't have any idea.
This theory was shaped over many years, but has been chipped away over the past summer and fall as I'm starting to think that maybe I am just being rather ignorant. Watching the Bob Dylan documentary, "No Direction Home", was the most offensive attack upon my completely unprovable theorem, as his lyrics are his songs. I went back to songs like "Desolation Row" and "Visions of Johanna" trying to see if I was missing something life-altering, but along the way I got side tracked by a song I was felt ashamed of liking. "I Want You" is that song on the greatest hits that no serious Bob Dylan fan is supposed to like, or at least this is what I thought when I was 14. While the other songs sounded deathly serious, this one always seemed like just another love song. The chorus, the part that I always knew, could come from any love-lorn singer of the past 50 years.
I want you, I want you,
I want you so bad,
Honey, I want you.
Not exactly the deepest comments, honest perhaps, but just look at the verse the precedes it:
The guilty undertaker sighs,
The lonesome organ grinder cries,
The silver saxophones say I should refuse you.
The cracked bells and washed-out horns
Blow into my face with scorn,
But it's not that way,
I wasn't born to lose you.
We are immediately shown death, an undertaker and organ grinder cries, all of which conjure images of a funeral, and perhaps a lover's one. But I don't believe he's talking about a death of his lover, as the next lines continue the musical motif that the "organ grinder cries" started. The silver saxophones and cracked bells continue with the decay, but really are there solely to mock him, as they blow on his face. The last line, "I wasn't born to lose you", changes from a typical line about not wanting to loose a loved one, to one of defiance. He is trying to get past what everyone is saying to him.
By the time the chorus comes, it looks much different than it did a paragraph ago. Instead of a repetitive love song, this song about longing, has gone through a funeral, direct scorn, and defiance. It is a line of tremendous weight, of real conviction. This is no weepy love song.
So how much of my life has been wasted because I wasn't recognizing the meaning behind the songs? Obviously the indie rock that fills my ears throughout most of the day is almost gibberish, not in the actual words but through the voice that delivers most of the words. Most favorite albums of the year are completely indecipherable: Clap Your Hands Say Yeah!, Animal Collective, Spoon, Sigur Ros.
Does this say more about me, that I'm unwilling to probe the depths of these songs to find the meaning, or that enjoyment does not hinge on the actual meaning of the song? Can a song can have completely different meanings to people and that is inherently okay, even if the original intent is mangled?
Moving on from Dylan I started examining other bands that I have known for a while, seeing if I could decipher a little meaning, all of which will be presented next time for my own particular enjoyment only.





